The Historical Register is a compilation of information on every
United Methodist Church in the Louisiana Annual Conference.
Acadiana
Alexandria
Baton Rouge
Lake Charles
Monroe
New Orleans
Shreveport
Hartzell United Methodist Church
City
New Orleans 
Address
 2014 Caffin Ave.
2003 Membership
 211
Date Founded
 1927
       A Methodist Missin began in 1926 at 1900 Andry Street, in the lower 9th Ward  The first members were Mr. and Mrs. James Dunson, their five children, Mrs. Mary Turner, her son, James, Mrs. Ruth Thibodeaux, Rev. J. O. Richards, Pastor of Thompson Methodist Episcopal Church, Rev. Daigle, another Methodist Minister, Mr. Leonard Brown, Sunday School Superintendent of Thompson Church and his two daughters.  This group met at 1900 Andry Street.
     In 1927, Rev. William Daily Martin and District Superintendent Rev. J.W. Turner met with the group, now meeting at Mary Turner's home on North Miro Street.  Mrs. Turner was the District Superintendent's sister-in-law.  
The church was incorporated on March 23, 1927 and was named after Bishop Hartzell. 
  .  Three lots were purchased on August 8, 1927 for $2,200.  The two homes on the lots were used as the church and parsonage.  Shortly after Rev. L.V. Blunt's arrival in 1928, the church building burned.  Services were held in the front two rooms of the parsonage for several years.  Rev. D.L. Riley, a carpenter by trade, began rebuilding the church in 1934.   A 1942 storm destroyed the still uncompleted church when Rev. T.E. McElroy was pastor.   After Rev. C.D. Small (another carpenter by trade) arrived in 1943, the church was finally completed.
     During Rev. Nathaniel Paul Williams' twenty-one year tenure, Annual Conference was held at Hartzell (1961). 
     After being damaged by hurricane Betsy, the church was rebuilt in 1966.  Services were temporarily held at Little Bethel African Methodist Church and Church of God during construction. 
.    Rev. James S. Davidson (who had been a member of Hartzell) served the church from 1978 to 1986.  The church's debt was retired under his leadership.
     In 1989, additions and renovations were made on the church.
How to Get There:
    From I-10, go east on N. Claiborne Ave.  (Hwy 39).  About 1/2 mile after crossing the Intercoastal, turn left onto Caffin Ave.  (You'll see the Martin Luther King Elementary School on the left at the intersection.)  Head north on Caffin past N. Johnson.  The church will be on the left.
Historical Register
Main Page
Archives & History
Main Page
Louisiana Conference
Main Page